When markets sell off together: why gold fell with stocks, and silver hit a one-year low
Gold is meant to hold up when other markets fall. On Monday it did not. That can look confusing, but it is a familiar pattern in fast sell-offs, and it does not change our view of gold's next big high in November 2027.
By Sonia Taneja ·
What happened on Monday
US share markets had a rough day. The S&P 500 fell close to 2%, and a widely watched measure of market fear rose by almost a fifth. A survey of New York manufacturers came in well below expectations.
Gold did not rise as a safe haven. It slipped about 0.3% to 0.6% and closed at its lowest level in more than a year. Silver fell around 3% to its lowest level in 12 months, and it is now close to 60% below its January record. The gold-to-silver ratio jumped to about 82, from close to 80 on Friday.
In the background, the same pressures as last week: the US 10-year bond yield above 5.1%, the dollar near its strongest level since April 2025, and markets pricing a Federal Reserve rate hike in December at above 90%.
Why gold can fall with stocks
Selling to raise cash. When share prices fall fast, some investors and funds that borrowed to invest face calls to put up more money. They often sell whatever they can sell quickly, and gold is one of the easiest assets to sell. In the first stage of a sell-off, that can push gold down alongside everything else.
Rising rates hit everything at once. This sell-off is driven by the prospect of higher US interest rates. Higher rates make shares less attractive and also raise the cost of holding gold, which pays no interest. So the same force is pushing on both.
A strong dollar. Investors moving into cash tend to move into dollars, and a stronger dollar weighs on gold priced in dollars.
Why silver fell harder
Silver has two roles. It is a precious metal like gold, but more than half of its use is in industry, from solar panels to electronics. On a day when markets are worried about growth and factory surveys disappoint, silver feels that worry on top of the rate and dollar pressure. That is why the gap between the two metals, the gold-to-silver ratio, widened sharply.
What usually happens next
In past sell-offs, gold falling alongside stocks has often been a first-stage reaction rather than a lasting one. Once the forced selling eases, gold has tended to recover its role faster than many other assets, especially when the sell-off raises questions about growth, debt or financial stress.
We cannot say when that turn will come this time. The rate and dollar pressures that have weighed on gold this month may last until the Fed's December meeting. But the pattern is worth knowing, because it explains why a falling gold price on a bad day for stocks is not, by itself, a sign that gold has lost its long-term appeal.
What to watch this week
Today, Tuesday: US retail sales for October, out at 8:30 am in New York, 7 pm in India. A strong number would add to the case for higher rates.
Wednesday: minutes of the Fed's October meeting, and results from Nvidia, which could move share markets sharply.
Share markets. If stocks keep falling, watch whether gold starts to separate from them. That has often been an early sign that the forced selling is ending.
What our AstroPlanetary view says
Our short-term reading is event-based and updates every hour. A day when shares, bonds and metals all move together is the kind of day it is built to follow. On the planetary side, the second half of November carries the shift in the Rahu–Ketu axis we have mentioned in earlier posts, with Jupiter turning retrograde in December. In our framework that goes with sudden, broad moves across markets rather than calm trends.
Our long-term view is unchanged. We see gold's next big high in November 2027, with ups and downs along the way. A one-year low is one of the downs, and it may not be the last before the year ends.
What we would do this month
We would stay away from short-term investing in gold and silver for the rest of November. On days like Monday, short-term positions can be caught in selling that has nothing to do with gold itself. For long-term holders, one useful habit is to look at why prices are falling, not only how far.
Everyone's situation is different. If you are making a decision about your own money, speak to a qualified financial adviser.
Get the day-by-day and longer-term view
The Bullion Signals app gives the short-term forecast updated every hour, the day-by-day view, and the medium and long-term outlook for gold and silver. See the passes, or read our long-term view: the next big high in November 2027.
Sources: market prices, yields and the dollar index as reported by USAGOLD, Fortune and Rio Times on 16 November 2026; New York Fed Empire State survey; CME FedWatch.
Educational research, not financial advice. Forecasts and readings are hypothetical model outputs, not guarantees or recommendations, and past results do not indicate future performance.